The Fine
Based on reportedly true events.
Let me tell you ‘bout the only time I ever been happy to cough up a fine levied by a politician.
Happened one night in the dead of winter—1935, or maybe it was ’36. That part don’t matter. But it was one of them cold days like only New York can deliver. You know what I’m sayin’—cold enough the wind goes straight through your coat like it’s got a grudge. My boots were soaked with slush and salt from the walk to court. The laces were stiff and white with dried salt, cracked like old rope. I remember that real clear.
The courthouse lobby smelled like wet wool, Lucky Strikes, and quiet misery. A couple guys stood hunched under the radiator grille like it owed them something. It didn’t pay up.
I was in night court, downtown. Fifth row back, fourth seat in. There to fight a lousy parking ticket. Three bucks. Don’t sound like much now, but back then, that was real money. Coulda filled a grocery sack. Hell, that’s what I made in a day, breakin’ my back under a Pontiac, breathin’ fumes and scrapin’ grease outta timing chains.
So yeah, I showed up. Not ‘cause I thought I’d win, but ‘cause sometimes a man’s gotta plant his boots in front of the machine and make it look him in the eye before it flattens him.
But the second I walked into that courtroom, I knew somethin’ was off.
First thing I noticed was the hush—the kind you get right before a fight breaks out or God walks in. Second thing? The guy on the bench.
It wasn’t some tired judge with a gravy tie and a gavel worn smooth. It was him.
Mayor Fiorello LaGuardia.
Swear to God. The Little Flower in the flesh, perched up there in rolled shirtsleeves like he owned the city—and maybe he did.
“Figured I’d see how justice feels at the street level,” he said, loud and smooth, like he was callin’ bingo. “Let’s proceed.”
A couple chuckles rolled through the room, but it wasn’t funny. Not with eyes like his—sharp, heavy, clockin’ everyone. He looked like a man takin’ inventory of a broken machine, piece by piece.
First case was a fruit vendor sellin’ without a permit. Then a guy caught pissin’ in an alley behind Macy’s. Then some poor girl accused of swipin’ lipstick. The place smelled like radiator steam, sweat, and fear. The bailiff kept suckin’ on menthol drops, breathin’ mint across everyone’s necks.
Then they called her.
The old woman.
She looked like a ghost in borrowed clothes—gray shawl, no hat, shoes wrapped in rags. She moved like life had stopped pushin’ her forward and gravity had taken over.
Her name was Maria, I think. The clerk had to repeat it twice before she shuffled forward. No lawyer. No family. Just her and those cracked leather shoes and the courtroom leanin’ in so tight you could hear the clock tick.
The charge?
Theft of a loaf of bread.
LaGuardia leaned forward. Hands clasped. No smile.
“Ma’am,” he said, quiet but firm, “Did you take the bread?”
She nodded, slow, like she was apologizin’ to the floorboards.
“Why?”
Her voice came out dry and thin. Like rust flakin’ off a pipe.
“My daughter passed last year. Her children—my grandchildren—are hungry. We had no heat last night. I went to the mission. The church. They said come back Tuesday.”
Somebody sniffled behind me. Not from the cold.
The mayor looked down at the docket, then back at her.
“The law’s the law,” he said. Voice tight. “Theft is theft. The fine is ten dollars.”
You could feel it. That ripple. Like he’d socked the whole room in the gut. Ten bucks. Might as well have been ten grand. The old woman didn’t flinch. Didn’t cry. Just stood there like it was all expected. Like she was already sentenced the moment she picked up that loaf.
Then LaGuardia did somethin’ I’ll never forget.
He reached into his coat, pulled out his own wallet, and peeled off a ten like he was payin’ for a newspaper.
“I’m payin’ this fine,” he said. Calm. Like steel under velvet. “But that’s not where this ends.”
He stood up, slow and deliberate.
“I’m finin’ everyone in this courtroom fifty cents—for livin’ in a city where a grandmother has to steal bread to feed her grandchildren. Bailiff, collect it—and then give it to this woman so she doesn’t have to steal a loaf tomorrow.”
For a beat, nobody moved.
Then the murmurs started. Confused. Uncertain. A couple of chuckles—nervous ones. One guy near the back muttered, “Is he kiddin’?” but he didn’t say it loud enough to test the man on the bench.
Now, I’ll be straight with you—at first, I was pissed. Fifty cents was lunch. Two beers and a corned beef at O’Malley’s. But then I looked at her. And I saw that look in her eyes. Not hope. Not quite. But close. Like she remembered what hope used to feel like.
And then I looked down at myself. At my beer keg of a belly obscuring the view of my feet. I could skip a sandwich or two for the old broad. Know what I’m sayin?”
The bailiff came down the aisle with a wooden cigar box. You could hear the coins hit—plink, clink, chime. Nickels. Quarters. Folded bills. The guy next to me—some guy in a bowler hat and wool coat—he dropped a five like it was pocket lint.
Then the box came to me.
And yeah—I hesitated.
I thought, “Five bucks? What am I, a schmuck?” But then I caught her again. And I knew.
I pulled out what I had. A couple quarters. Some dimes. Nickels. Even tossed in a dozen pennies. All the shrapnel I had left. Held back the three bucks in case they still made me pay the parking ticket.
In the end, she walked outta that courtroom with forty-seven dollars and some change. You shoulda seen her hands tremblin’ when they gave it to her. The mayor put her in his car himself and told the driver to take her home.
No speech. No ceremony.
Just, “Feed those children.”
Then he walked back in like he’d just taken a phone call and sat back down behind the bench.
“Thomas Rizzo,” he said.
That was me.
I stood. Heart poundin’.
“Parking violation, corner of Canal and Mulberry,” he read. “Crosswalk infraction.”
I swallowed hard. “Your Honor, I—uh—I was workin’ late. There was a delivery truck double-parked, and I didn’t see the—”
He held up a hand.
“How much is the fine?”
“Three dollars.”
He looked at me with them eyes again. Like he was weighin’ my soul on a scale only he could see.
“Had that shop awhile, have you?”
I nodded.
“Well then you knew the law. Stop wastin’ our time and pay your fine.”
Bam. Gavel.
I paid it.
Walked outta that courtroom with an empty wallet and a full chest. My boots still squished. My coat still smelled like oil and iron. I missed lunch for the next couple days. But I felt like a million bucks.
Didn’t do me no harm.
But somethin’ in me had shifted. Like a rusted bolt finally turned loose.
So yeah—go ahead and file this story under miracles, or bullshit, or whatever you want.
That’s the God’s honest truth. Exactly how it happened.
Like I said: Only time I ever felt proud to pay a fine levied by a politician.
And if I could go back?
I’d pay it again.
With interest.
Author’s Note
This story is based on a widely reported and likely true event from Mayor Fiorello LaGuardia’s time in office. Multiple sources recount him paying the fine of a woman who stole bread to feed her grandchildren, then fining everyone in the courtroom fifty cents for allowing a city to exist where such desperation was possible.
While the incident itself is believed to be true, the narrator—Thomas Rizzo—and his voice are fictional, created to bring the moment to life through the eyes of an ordinary New Yorker who might’ve been there to witness it.
Adjusted for inflation, the fifty cents LaGuardia charged each person in 1935 equals about $11.67 today. The woman’s $10 fine would be about $233.43, and the $47 she walked away with that night? Roughly $1,097.12 in today’s dollars.
A note from Sev:
The preceding story was free. I release 3 free stories per week and 5 premium stories for just $8.99 per month or $79 per year.
If you read and enjoyed it, please honor my efforts by sharing it on Facebook, X, BlueSky, and of course re-stack it here in Substack!
Also, your comments and messages (and smart Alec remarks) are always appreciated. Take a moment to help the algorithm find me by starting or joining the discussion.
I cannot grow this without your help! As they say, “Teamwork makes the dream work!”
Please and Thank you!
Sev